
Making the multi-country model work
In 2021, DFAT will decide whether or not it wishes to exercise the option to renew MDF Phase II for a further five-year term. At the end of a testing year and with an impending mid-term review, it is worth looking back to consider whether or not the multi-country model has achieved its objectives.
The starting point is to reflect on what MDF was designed to achieve. Market Systems Development (MSD) programs, like other aid modalities, are effective when they are implemented well. Conversely, like other aid modalities, MSD programs can meander and achieve little when implemented poorly. More than others, MSD programs are sensitive to the quality of the implementation team. That was the constraint that MDF was designed to address. In small economies with shallow labour markets, it is challenging to recruit and train a qualified team within the required timeframe. Extensive use of international advisors is prohibitively expensive and, ultimately, self-defeating. Without the right team, any MSD program in thin market contexts is more likely than not to be ineffective. The efficiency case for small, standalone MSD programs in small-island economies did not stack up.




